The Intermediary – November 2026 - Flipbook - Page 80
P RO T E C T I O N
Opinion
Perfect is the
enemy of good
W
hen traditional
income
protection (IP)
is unsuitable,
unavailable or
unaffordable,
what happens next? For too many
clients, the conversation ends without
another option being explored.
That is where the principle that
“some protection is beer than
none” needs to become a practical
consideration, rather than simply an
industry talking point.
Comprehensive IP should remain
the starting point. But when it
cannot meet a client’s circumstances
or budget, the search for the
ideal solution should not prevent
consideration of suitable alternatives.
Some is better than none
74% of financial advisers agree that
some IP, even if more limited, is beer
than no protection. Yet 81% rarely or
never discuss accident-only income
protection (AOIP). Only half (50%)
routinely explore an alternative when
traditional IP isn’t possible.
The findings from National
Friendly’s ‘Bruised Britain 2026:
Accidents, Advisers & Access’
highlight a fundamental challenge:
recognising the value of alternative
cover is one thing, routinely
incorporating it into advice is another.
Six in 10 advisers (61%) regard
alternative products as a solid fallback
when traditional IP is not possible,
while 45% see them as a steppingstone to full IP. Only 2% identify the
perceived value of alternatives as a
barrier to recommending them.
Yet these alternative products
remain outside most routine
protection conversations. Advisers
estimate that nearly one in four (23%)
clients where traditional IP is not
suitable or available do not take out
any other type of policy to protect
their income (that includes life,
critical illness cover, AOIP, ASU, MPPI
78
The Intermediary | November 2026
etc) – walking away unprotected. So,
if advisers believe some is beer than
none, why is that not consistently
reflected in their recommendations?
The research suggests the gap
is driven less by opposition to
alternatives than by the practicalities
of finding, understanding and
recommending them. 31% of advisers
cite limited availability or visibility
on sourcing systems as a barrier. A
quarter (25%) point to a lack of clarity
about product comparisons, while
18% identify compliance or network
restrictions.
A third of advisers (33%) are
unfamiliar with the alternative
products available, while a further
49% are only ‘fairly familiar’.
Improving access requires more
than encouraging advisers to have
additional conversations. These
challenges are for the wider industry
to address. Insurers, sourcing
providers and networks all have a
role in making products visible,
comparable, and straightforward to
assess against individual client needs
Almost a quarter of advisers (24%)
cite a lack of client demand. However,
our consumer research suggests there
is an appetite worth exploring.
More than four in 10 UK adults
(44%) would expect to be told about
accident-only cover during a general
IP conversation with an adviser,
bank or comparison service. Among
Generation Z, this rises to 48%.
Meanwhile, 15% of UK adults,
equivalent to approximately 8.25
million people, would consider more
limited or shorter-term income
protection if traditional IP were
unavailable or too expensive.
This suggests a disconnect between
advisers’ expectations and consumers’
willingness to consider alternatives.
Clients cannot express a preference
for products they have not been told
about, and a lack of spontaneous
demand should not be mistaken for
a lack of need.
GIFFORD CLAY
is head of intermediary sales
at National Friendly
Rethinking good advice
Of course, our findings come amid
wider concern about financial
resilience. The Financial Conduct
Authority (FCA) found that 58%
of adults hold no protection,
highlighting the scale of the
challenge, particularly among people
with less stable incomes and lower
financial resilience.
Accident-only and short-term cover
offer different ways to meet part of a
client’s needs when comprehensive
IP does not fit. Their value lies in
providing support that suits the
client’s circumstances and budget,
with a clear understanding of what
is covered, for how long, and where
gaps remain.
For someone unable to afford full
IP, a more restricted policy may still
provide a valuable financial safety
net and a first step towards broader
protection as circumstances change.
The question is not whether
alternatives can replace traditional IP,
but whether clients are being given
an informed opportunity to consider
them. If three-quarters of advisers
already believe some protection is
beer than none, the next step is
translating that into practice through
beer product visibility, clearer
comparisons and more informed
conversations.
We’re working with the Income
Protection Task Force (IPTF) to shine
a light on alternatives to traditional
IP and help advisers explore more
ways to protect their clients. When
traditional options are unsuitable,
unavailable or unaffordable, the aim
is to keep the conversation going and
help more access valuable cover. ●