The Intermediary – November 2026 - Flipbook - Page 74
S E C O N D C H A RG E
Opinion
Second charge has
lost its favourite
sales pitch
F
or several years, the
second charge market
had a very compelling
sales pitch. Why
remortgage your entire
balance when you’re
siing on a first charge at 2% or 3%? It
was simple, easy to understand and, in
many cases, right for the customer.
But markets move on. Many of
those historically low fixed-rate
deals have matured, or are reaching
maturity, and the gap between first
and second charge pricing isn’t always
as dramatic as it once was.
That weakens one of the easiest
rationales for a second charge. And
I think that’s a good thing. If second
charge is going to cement its position
as a mainstream option, it must be
able to stand on its own merits, rather
than rely on a quirk of the interest
rate cycle. Consumers don’t set out
to optimise their credit structure
by arbitraging the relative costs of
marginal debt and total debt. They
choose a second charge because it’s a
suitable product.
A healthier comparison
The consideration for advisers today
is becoming more nuanced. For a
customer looking to raise capital,
there might be a remortgage, further
advance or second charge solution that
all look reasonably competitive.
Rather than asking whether a
customer has a cheap first charge that
needs protecting, look harder at what
they are actually trying to achieve.
How much do they need to borrow?
How quickly do they need it? What’s
driving the need to borrow? How long
do they expect to borrow for? Do they
need flexibility to repay early? What
is their affordability picture? Does it
make sense to restructure their entire
mortgage to raise a relatively small
72
The Intermediary | November 2026
additional amount? The answer is not
automatically a second charge. Nor
should it be. But neither should it be a
remortgage.
Speed matters
One area where second charge has
built a much stronger case is speed.
Technology and automation have
transformed what a modern second
charge journey can look like.
But speed shouldn’t simply be
something lenders boast about on a
service update. For some customers
it’s not an added benefit or a nice to
do, it’s a necessity. People oen need
to raise money because something is
happening in their lives: a renovation
is running over budget, a large expense
has arisen, a business opportunity
has appeared, credit card debt is
snowballing or another financial
commitment needs dealing with.
Those circumstances do not always
fit neatly around the timeline of a
conventional mortgage transaction.
If two suitable options are relatively
close on price, but one gives the
customer access to the funds they need
considerably sooner, that maers.
Flexibility has a value
A second charge allows additional
borrowing to be structured separately.
Depending on the product, that can
give customers choices around term
and repayment that reflect the purpose
of the additional borrowing.
That distinction becomes
increasingly important as the old price
argument becomes less clear-cut. It
also forces us to think more carefully
about what we mean by ‘value’.
The lowest interest rate? The lowest
monthly payment? The cheapest total
cost? The quickest route to funds? The
smallest fee? The solution that best fits
what the customer expects to do in two
JONNY JONES
is CEO at Interbridge Mortgages
or three years? There will rarely be
one winner across every measure.
Every customer is different, and
that’s exactly why advice maers.
Second charge lending is already
operating at significant scale. The
latest Financing & Leasing Association
(FLA) figures show £2.39bn of new
business in the 12 months to August
2026, up 24% year-on-year.
But August itself provided an
interesting reality check: new
agreement volumes fell 3% year-onyear, only the second monthly fall
reported in 2026. Is this an issue?
Maybe not. The next test for this
market isn’t how quickly it can grow,
but whether it can continue to earn
its place as the mortgage landscape
changes. I believe it can. Not because
it should always beat a remortgage
on rate. And not because we need
another campaign telling brokers
that second charge exists. It will
earn its place because, for the right
customer, it can offer a combination of
speed, flexibility and a more targeted
approach to additional borrowing.
Sometimes the remortgage will win.
Sometimes the second charge will. A
mature market should be comfortable
with that. What maers is that the
customer gets the solution that works
best for their circumstances, not the
one that happens to fit the easiest sales
narrative. For advisers, that means
looking beyond rate and considering
speed, flexibility, and the purpose of
the borrowing in the round.
Because if second charge is really
becoming part of the mainstream
mortgage conversation, it shouldn’t
need a 2% first charge to make the
case for it. There is far more to second
charge mortgages than that! ●