The Intermediary – November 2026 - Flipbook - Page 60
BUY-TO-LET
Opinion
The growing
HMO paradox
T
here is a paradox
developing around
houses in multiple
occupation (HMOs),
These properties play an
increasingly important
role in the private rented sector (PRS),
but are becoming harder to create in
parts of the country.
Shared accommodation can
provide a more affordable option at
a time when the cost of renting an
entire property is challenging. For
experienced landlords, the right
HMO in the right location can deliver
aractive income, as well as a way to
diversify a wider portfolio.
PlanningLens found that, across
a consistent sample of 144 English
councils, the number of HMO
applications decided increased by 87%
between 2021 and 2025. Over the same
period, refusals more than doubled,
from 590 to 1,203, while the overall
approval rate fell from 68.1% to 65.2%.
Of course, there are good reasons for
councils to take a considered approach
to HMOs, given the implications
that the quality and concentration of
shared accommodation can have for
tenants and the wider community.
However, at a time when the rental
market needs a broad range of goodquality accommodation, we also need
to consider whether we are making it
unnecessarily difficult for responsible,
experienced landlords to provide it.
An effective option
HMOs sometimes suffer from being
treated as a single category, when
in reality there can be an enormous
difference between individual
properties, the landlords operating
them, and the tenants they serve.
There can be a misconception
that HMOs are simply about fiing
as many tenants in as possible.
Experienced operators understand
that location, configuration,
management and the quality of
the accommodation all maer,
58
The Intermediary | November 2026
alongside licensing and regulatory
responsibilities. The investment case
needs to stand up on its own merits as
well. Yes, HMOs can generate stronger
rental income than a conventional
single let, but that must be considered
against the higher management
requirements, running costs,
licensing, maintenance and capital
required to keep the property at the
appropriate standard.
HMOs tend to appeal particularly
to landlords who understand the
sector and are prepared to take
a more active approach to their
portfolios, recognising that a higher
headline income doesn’t necessarily
translate automatically into a beer
investment.
We’re continuing to see professional
landlords consider HMOs alongside
conventional buy-to-let (BTL),
multi-unit blocks (MUBs) and semicommercial property, and for me, this
isn’t necessarily about replacing one
type of investment with another.
Landlords are becoming more
deliberate about the role individual
properties play within a wider
portfolio – the income they can
produce, the diversification, the
amount of capital required and how
they fit with longer-term plans.
Getting the balance right
Local authorities need to be able
to protect housing standards and
consider the impact concentrations of
HMOs can have on individual areas.
But equally, we need to be careful
that in addressing legitimate concerns
we don’t create barriers that make it
unnecessarily difficult for experienced
landlords to deliver good-quality
shared accommodation where there is
genuine tenant demand.
The local planning position can
also influence whether an otherwise
aractive investment is viable. Strong
demand and rental proposition
are important, but they cannot be
considered in isolation.
ALEX UPTON
is managing director, specialist
mortgages and bridging finance
at Hampshire Trust Bank
Finance has a part to play in
geing that balance right, too. For
professional landlords, leverage isn’t
simply about borrowing as much as
possible, but deciding where their
capital works hardest across
the portfolio. Puing more equity into
one property may reduce borrowing
on that particular asset, but it can
also leave less capital available for
refurbishment, improving existing
properties or pursuing the next
investment opportunity.
Experienced landlords are
increasingly looking at those decisions
across the portfolio as a whole, rather
than viewing the funding of each
property entirely in isolation.
For some landlords, borrowing at a
lower LTV will continue to be the right
approach, while for others, retaining
more capital within the business may
allow them to invest elsewhere in the
portfolio, carry out improvements or
maintain greater liquidity.
Greater financial flexibility and
higher property standards don’t need
to be opposing objectives.
Seeing the whole picture
HMOs won’t be appropriate for
every landlord or every location,
and nor should they be. However,
good-quality shared accommodation
has an important place within the
rental market.
If the tenant need is there, and
experienced, responsible landlords
are prepared to invest to meet it, then
we need to ensure that planning,
investment and finance can work
together rather than unnecessarily
against one another.
Otherwise, it is the tenants who end
up paying the price. ●