The Intermediary – November 2026 - Flipbook - Page 44
RESIDENTIAL
Opinion
The ‘standard
borrower’ no
longer exists
P
icture two mortgage
applicants. One is a
contractor with five
years of day rates
behind them. The other
is a salaried employee
six months into their first job. Which
is the bigger risk?
I’d argue the contractor is no riskier.
Yet in much of today’s mortgage
market, the salaried employee is easier
to approve, simply because the lending
model finds them easier to score.
To me, that points to a problem the
industry has been slow to confront.
For decades, the mortgage market
has operated on the unspoken idea
of a ‘standard borrower’. They have
a regular salary, clean credit history,
uninterrupted career, and income
that arrives in the same shape
every month.
That borrower still exists, but they
are no longer the whole picture. Selfemployment, contract work, multiple
incomes, career changes and time
out for caring or ill health are now
ordinary features of working life.
Modern lives
People can feel the mismatch.
Research from our latest report, ‘The
Doorstep Divide’, found that just 30%
of adults feel the mortgage market
is designed for people like them,
while just 27% believe the application
process is fair.
It’s easy to see why. Someone who’s
freelance, recently divorced or made
redundant may be perfectly able to
afford a mortgage. Their finances just
need a closer look. But too oen the
system mistakes that extra work for
extra risk, and the borrower is either
turned down or le waiting so long
they walk away.
These are not unusual borrowers.
They are modern ones. More than
42
The Intermediary | November 2026
two-thirds (68%) of brokers believe
borrowers with non-standard
circumstances will soon be the norm,
and almost a third (31%) say they
already are. Even so, 88% of brokers
say lenders have been too slow to
respond, and I think that’s a fair
challenge for all of us.
Almost half (49%) of self-employed,
freelance and variable income workers
told us they had delayed, dropped
out of, or decided against a mortgage
application because of how they earn.
Many have not been declined; they
simply assume they won’t be heard.
That is lost business for brokers, lost
lending for the market and, for the
borrower, a home that may have been
within reach.
Not the same as risk
I know what some people may be
thinking: this sounds like a return
to risky lending. Of course, I’m not
suggesting that. Affordability is nonnegotiable, and responsible lending
protects borrowers as much as it
protects lenders.
But complexity is not the same as
risk, and a borrower with blended
income or a recent career break may
need more context without being less
able to repay.
Brokers already do much of that
work and oen stop creditworthy
applicants counting themselves
out. Lenders can make that easier
or harder.
Clear, consistent criteria, a quick
route to an underwriter when a case
doesn’t fit the scorecard, and decisions
in principle that don’t automatically
fail applicants with complex
income profiles would all help ease
the process.
I’d also like to see proven rental
history given the weight it deserves.
For many first-time buyers, rent is
AARON SHINWELL
is chief lending officer at
Nottingham Building Society
their largest monthly commitment,
and years of paying it in full and
on time say a great deal about how
they would manage a mortgage,
yet it rarely shows up on a standard
credit file.
Many people agree: 77% told us
paying rent on time should count as
evidence of creditworthiness.
Changing with people
At Noingham Building Society,
labels such as ‘self-employed’ or ‘career
break’ are where the conversation
starts, not where it ends.
What maers is how income has
been earned over time, whether it
is sustainable and what someone’s
position looks like today. We’ve been
lending for more than 175 years, and
I believe we’ve lasted that long by
changing with the people we serve,
not by holding on to how things used
to be done.
No single lender can close this
gap alone. Lenders, brokers and
policymakers need to work together to
make mortgage decisions clearer and
fairer for people whose circumstances
do not fit the traditional mould.
The ‘standard borrower’ was always
a simplification, and the market now
has an opportunity to build a process
that works just as well for those with
complex, credible circumstances as
it does for those whose finances fit
neatly on a payslip. ●